Roger,
I told you on Sunday that it was time to show your true colors, and boy have you!
See if you can see any irony in what Chris Jenkins from the AP reported (these are direct quotes):
------------------------------
"The NFL fined Green Bay Packers safety Nick Collins $50,000 on Monday for his helmet-to-helmet hit on Dallas Cowboys wide receiver Roy Williams.
In a statement, league officials said Collins “violently and unnecessarily struck a defenseless receiver” in the neck and head area with his helmet during Sunday night’s game at Lambeau Field and called it a “flagrant violation of player safety rules.”
Collins went helmet-to-helmet with Williams after an incompletion in the third quarter of the Packers’ 45-7 victory over the Cowboys Sunday night. Collins was flagged for unnecessary roughness.
Williams said after the game that he didn’t think NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell should punish Collins for the hit.
“Commissioner Goodell, don’t fine the guy,” Williams said. “It wasn’t that bad of a deal, he shouldn’t get fined. It was a football play, a football player making a football play. No injury, no harm.”
-------------------
So, let's check this out for a moment. You are fining Mr. Collins when the person he hit, Roy Williams, replies "no injury, no harm" and "it wasn't that bad of a deal." I am not sure Mr. Williams is a 100% there, but it is quite ironic the man who got hit is shrugging his shoulders over this.
Meanwhile, it's time to look at Sunday's topic ... oh you know Mr. Roger Goodell, the guy who can't play this week and who captivated millions on Sunday as he lay there being fastened to a stretcher - Colts receiver Austin Collie.
So what again did Chris Jenkins from the AP again report?
-----------------------------------------
The NFL did not hand out any discipline for the hit that gave Indianapolis wide receiver Austin Collie a concussion in Philadelphia on Sunday.
Collie was hit by safety Quintin Mikell, then took a shot to the helmet from fellow safety Kurt Coleman’s helmet in the second quarter. Collie briefly lost consciousness and was taken off the field by stretcher.
Coleman was penalized for unnecessary roughness.
The NFL said because the helmet-to-helmet contact was a result of Collie being driven toward Coleman by Mikell’s legal hit, there will be no fine. The league said game officials have been instructed to err on the side of player safety, and when in doubt, “penalize in situations such as this for unnecessary roughness.”
-------------------
Now Roger - I think you happen to be a pretty smart guy - aren't you a lawyer? Why don't you think about this instead of from the standpoint of a defense attorney (who of course always just want to get their clients off, such as the NFL for instance), try playing a personal injury lawyer.
There is no question that Collie's helmet was hit by Coleman. There's also no question that Collie's injuries can be attributed to Coleman, and let's think out of the box. Coleman had a choice to make - hit the guy without hitting his head (those are YOUR guidelines remember), or guess what? He can NOT hit him.
You could flip sides and become like James Harrison (you know, the guy who you fined $100,000 for his consistent acts to injure players) and say "I am here to HURT people." But hey, this is a guy you are never going to suspend either - why?
You got it - Roger won't suspend players while their colleagues lie in the hospital, talking to loved ones and wondering if they will be the same after their "contact" with opposing players.
What is so irritating Mr. Commissioner is that the player hurt the worst who will be missing games must enjoy knowing his employer is telling him that's part of the job. Never mind that it could be prevented or that the league could use it as an opportunity to show that it is serious about stopping guys from literally trying to knock each others' heads off.
Instead, you'll claim to be tough but find another hit where the person hit laughs it of - "not so BAD of a deal."
Sounds like I need to try another argument Roger.
Well, I obviously am no lawyer - so don't worry about me the next time a few of your employees are unconscious, need to be revived, and one day cured for Dementia.
Sports Audit
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
Sunday, November 7, 2010
Show Us Your True Colors Roger Goodell
Colts wide receiver Austin Collie too a helmet to helmet, "helmet shot," "helmet hit," or "head shot" (we've seen so many of them this season that who knows what the proper term is) when Kurt Coleman applied the latest horror to NFL football fans everywhere. Meanwhile, CBS's Bill Cowher, Shannon Sharpe, and Dan Marino all defended Coleman and made their messages clear to the NFL commissioner as they were being paid to promote the same very league.
A few weeks ago, Roger Goodell claimed that the league was clamping down on helmet hits by threatening to suspend players. Of course, heaven forbid he actually suspend a player! It sure looks by now that he has no intention to, especially when his PR agency (er TV commentators, who just all happened to make their life's living form the NFL) included one of the most beloved former coaches Bill Cowher imploring Goodell not to suspend Coleman for leaving a fellow player unconcious on the field by says it was part of football.
Sooner or later, one of the paralyzed players is going to have a terrific lawsuit against the NFL as the league is now already on the record to prevent such horrors and sending memos and making executives available for interviews.
But the players continue to lay their unconscious, motionless, and treat the NFL fans to 10 minutes plus of horror each and every time one of these "legal" (to some) shots are landed primarily by a defensive player.
So, now the NFL can enjoy this problem from two sides - since it truly has done nothing that actually stopped the problem yet. Until a player is suspended for as long as the player he injured, the deterrent is not there.
Remember the argument for the death penalty? If you put someone to death, you are sending the messsage.
The NFL, on the other hand, just punsishes one of its worst offenders (James Harrison) $100,000 of his $5 million plus salary. And oh by the way, he was not suspended for saying the NFL will not let him play football and he could not stop himself from hitting people like he has been doing - or another way of saying "I can't help treating the fans and TV viewers to more horrors - it is football."
Then there are the lame excuses that the NFL profits on videos of cheap shots. Wonder how much money the NFL derives from DVD sales each year as compared to TV revenues and ticket/sponsor revenue. You must be kidding. None of those videos show people unconscious and take advantage of player's horrific experiences.
Roger - I want you to think of something... your worst fear. If, one day a player will die on the field on live TV from one of these shots you say you are trying so hard to prevent, how would you like to start facing Congress just like the baseball people did? By the way, how has that been for baseball since Congress invited some of the star players for a little pow wow on national TV?
But let's not also forget the worst possible scenario for you Roger - what if the networks might consider re-structuring their TV deals after a player dies on national TV? It certainly would be a stretch, but look back at boxer Ray Mancini's legendary fight that forever has taken boxing off the major networks.
Even if we just stay with the simplest, most conservative analysis, the NFL gave ample warning and fines so that it can claim it does not want to see players lying on the ground motionless and unconscious. The league has issued multiple fines since that announcement but to date, has never taken the step it has threatened - suspension.
Roger - it's time to see how much of a good businessman and good person you are. Unconscious motionless employees is not good for business, especially on TV. And if you are a good person, it's time for you to prove that you really think that head is too fragile an area for the human weapons you employ to target.
What will it be Roger?
A few weeks ago, Roger Goodell claimed that the league was clamping down on helmet hits by threatening to suspend players. Of course, heaven forbid he actually suspend a player! It sure looks by now that he has no intention to, especially when his PR agency (er TV commentators, who just all happened to make their life's living form the NFL) included one of the most beloved former coaches Bill Cowher imploring Goodell not to suspend Coleman for leaving a fellow player unconcious on the field by says it was part of football.
Sooner or later, one of the paralyzed players is going to have a terrific lawsuit against the NFL as the league is now already on the record to prevent such horrors and sending memos and making executives available for interviews.
But the players continue to lay their unconscious, motionless, and treat the NFL fans to 10 minutes plus of horror each and every time one of these "legal" (to some) shots are landed primarily by a defensive player.
So, now the NFL can enjoy this problem from two sides - since it truly has done nothing that actually stopped the problem yet. Until a player is suspended for as long as the player he injured, the deterrent is not there.
Remember the argument for the death penalty? If you put someone to death, you are sending the messsage.
The NFL, on the other hand, just punsishes one of its worst offenders (James Harrison) $100,000 of his $5 million plus salary. And oh by the way, he was not suspended for saying the NFL will not let him play football and he could not stop himself from hitting people like he has been doing - or another way of saying "I can't help treating the fans and TV viewers to more horrors - it is football."
Then there are the lame excuses that the NFL profits on videos of cheap shots. Wonder how much money the NFL derives from DVD sales each year as compared to TV revenues and ticket/sponsor revenue. You must be kidding. None of those videos show people unconscious and take advantage of player's horrific experiences.
Roger - I want you to think of something... your worst fear. If, one day a player will die on the field on live TV from one of these shots you say you are trying so hard to prevent, how would you like to start facing Congress just like the baseball people did? By the way, how has that been for baseball since Congress invited some of the star players for a little pow wow on national TV?
But let's not also forget the worst possible scenario for you Roger - what if the networks might consider re-structuring their TV deals after a player dies on national TV? It certainly would be a stretch, but look back at boxer Ray Mancini's legendary fight that forever has taken boxing off the major networks.
Even if we just stay with the simplest, most conservative analysis, the NFL gave ample warning and fines so that it can claim it does not want to see players lying on the ground motionless and unconscious. The league has issued multiple fines since that announcement but to date, has never taken the step it has threatened - suspension.
Roger - it's time to see how much of a good businessman and good person you are. Unconscious motionless employees is not good for business, especially on TV. And if you are a good person, it's time for you to prove that you really think that head is too fragile an area for the human weapons you employ to target.
What will it be Roger?
Sunday, October 3, 2010
Ryder Cup - Blah Blah Blah
Who can seriously be interested in the Ryder Cup? Reminiscent of a 1950s style with today's golfers donning these retro sweater vests one would expect to see at an elite prep school or a private country club that only the most wealthy can join, the Ryder Cup is a perfect illustration of how out of touch the sport is with today's society.
Recall a few weeks ago when the golfer conceded his top prize to "self report" a mistake he had made. Not even in tennis today do athletes ever "self report" and concede their victory to their competitor(s).
But the Ryder Cup is so blah blah blah for many more reasons than the elitism so pervasive in the sport and its at times petty as can be rules.
How many other competitions exist showcasing American versus Europe? Never mind that Asian golfers do not matter enough for the Americans to measure themselves against. And why does it matter if America beats Europe in golf? What does that tell anyone?
The greatest multinational sports competitions involve countries individually competing against each other. The Olympics and World Cup make the Ryder Cup look irrelevant in the global sports landscape. After all, if you are a golfer, would you rather win the US Open, British Open, PGA, or even one of the elite tournaments OR would you rather go play with a bunch of your friends for what amounts to a high brow pissing contest by players, coaches, and even the media. Seriously, who cares who wins?
But it is not just the Olympics and World Cup that make the Ryder Cup look trivial. Even the World Baseball Classic had more significance (we are talking baseball here, not exactly a global sport if you consider how well Europe and Africa play the sport). For the Europeans, there is more interest in hockey's world championships (the Olympics is not the only national competition for hockey) and even basketball has its own version of a global championship, which the US just played. Even tennis, the closest sport to golf in terms of its elitism (and it does not come close), has the Davis Cup.
So country club presidents, er golf head honchos, how about a truly global competition. Re-live World War II with the Americans against the Japanese - how is that for tradition? Or, how about France against Spain for whose men are more romantic, on the golf course of course.
Get rid of the fraternity like "teams" of men wearing private school sweater vests, and let's start putting your players in their country's colors on the golf course.
Not only will you have more than just a weekend of entertainment to promote and profit from, someone will actually care who wins at each and every stage of the competition.
But with the score 9.6 to 6.5, maybe all the golf chiefs want to do is have a score like the America's Cup. Guess what? Another America versus the World competition that is blah blah blah.
Recall a few weeks ago when the golfer conceded his top prize to "self report" a mistake he had made. Not even in tennis today do athletes ever "self report" and concede their victory to their competitor(s).
But the Ryder Cup is so blah blah blah for many more reasons than the elitism so pervasive in the sport and its at times petty as can be rules.
How many other competitions exist showcasing American versus Europe? Never mind that Asian golfers do not matter enough for the Americans to measure themselves against. And why does it matter if America beats Europe in golf? What does that tell anyone?
The greatest multinational sports competitions involve countries individually competing against each other. The Olympics and World Cup make the Ryder Cup look irrelevant in the global sports landscape. After all, if you are a golfer, would you rather win the US Open, British Open, PGA, or even one of the elite tournaments OR would you rather go play with a bunch of your friends for what amounts to a high brow pissing contest by players, coaches, and even the media. Seriously, who cares who wins?
But it is not just the Olympics and World Cup that make the Ryder Cup look trivial. Even the World Baseball Classic had more significance (we are talking baseball here, not exactly a global sport if you consider how well Europe and Africa play the sport). For the Europeans, there is more interest in hockey's world championships (the Olympics is not the only national competition for hockey) and even basketball has its own version of a global championship, which the US just played. Even tennis, the closest sport to golf in terms of its elitism (and it does not come close), has the Davis Cup.
So country club presidents, er golf head honchos, how about a truly global competition. Re-live World War II with the Americans against the Japanese - how is that for tradition? Or, how about France against Spain for whose men are more romantic, on the golf course of course.
Get rid of the fraternity like "teams" of men wearing private school sweater vests, and let's start putting your players in their country's colors on the golf course.
Not only will you have more than just a weekend of entertainment to promote and profit from, someone will actually care who wins at each and every stage of the competition.
But with the score 9.6 to 6.5, maybe all the golf chiefs want to do is have a score like the America's Cup. Guess what? Another America versus the World competition that is blah blah blah.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)